The Effectiveness of Vermiculture in Human Pathogen
Reduction for USEPA Biosolids Stabilization
Bruce R. Eastman1, Philip N. Kane2, Clive A. Edwards3, Linda Trytek4,
Bintoro Gunadi3, Andrea L. Stermer1 and Jacquelyn R. Mobley 1
1. Orange County Environmental Protection Division, Orlando, Florida
2. Florida Department of Environmental Protection, Orlando, Florida
3. Soil Ecology Laboratory, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio
4. Tri-Tech Laboratories, Inc., Orlando, Florida
A field experiment tested the feasibility of vermicomposting as a method for eliminating
human pathogens to obtain United States Environmental Protection Agency
(USEPA) Class A stabilization in domestic wastewater residuals (biosolids). The experimental
site was at the City of Ocoee’s Wastewater Treatment Facility in Ocoee,
Florida, and Class B biosolids were used as the earthworm substrate. Two windrows
of biosolids 6 m long were heavily inoculated with four human-pathogen indicators,
fecal coliforms, Salmonella spp., enteric viruses and helminth ova. The test row was
seeded with earthworms, Eisenia fetida. The quantity of E. fetida was calculated at a
1:1.5 wet weight earthworm biomass to biosolids ratio and the earthworms allowed
time to consume the biosolids and stabilize the biosolids. The test indicated that all of
the pathogen indicators in the test row were decreased more than in the control row
within 144 hours. The test row samples showed a 6.4-log reduction in fecal coliforms
compared with the control row, which only had a 1.6-log reduction. The test row samples
showed an 8.6-log reduction in Salmonella spp., while the control row had a 4.9-
log reduction. The test row samples showed a 4.6-log reduction in enteric viruses
while the control only had a 1.8-log reduction. The test row samples had a 1.9-log reduction
in helminth ova while the control row only had a 0.6-log reduction. Dr. Jim
Smith, Senior Environmental Engineer and Pathogen Equivalency Commission
(PEC) Chair, for the USEPA, indicated by personal communications, that a three- to
four-fold reduction in indicator organisms would be sufficient to warrant serious consideration
of vermicomposting as an effective stabilization methodology (Smith
1997). These results in conjunction with pilot project results strongly indicate that vermicomposting
could be used as an alternative method for Class A biosolids stabilization.
This was obtained statistically by vermicomposting.